Our Menu
We use fresh ingredients and homemade recipes. If you have any questions, please ask us. We won't bite! Sales tax is included in all prices.
APPETIZERS
$11
Peel & Eat Shrimp
Chilled Key West pink shrimp, served with cocktail dipping sauce.
$11
$9
Crispy Calamari
Lightly fried calamari rings, served with Mama D.’s homemade marinara.
$9
$9
Overseas Conch Bites
Lightly fried conch fritters, served with key lime dijon dipping sauce.
$9
$9
Real Deal Buffalo Wings
The best Buffalo wings cooked to perfection in our signature Broaster, drenched in your choice of Garlic Parmesan, BBQ, Buffalo, or Teriyaki sauce.
$9
$8
The Sandilla Quesadilla
Our daughter Sandi’s favorite signature quesadilla, made with a 3-cheese blend and marinated tomatoes. Add broasted chicken (+4), grilled shrimp (+6), or braised pot roast (+6).
$8
$13
Casey’s Tuna Tataki
Seared sushi-grade tuna the way our daughter Casey likes it, served with a ginger-wasabi seaweed salad.
$13
Soups & Salads
Cup $4 | Bowl $6
Our Favorite Seasonal Soup
Ask your server about today’s homemade soup.
Cup $4 | Bowl $6
$6
Overseas Ice Cold Salad
Crisp mixed greens served ice cold with fresh seasonal veggies.
$6
$6
Sid’s Caesar
Fresh romaine served ice cold, topped with shaved reggiano parmesan cheese and homemade crunchy croutons. Anchovies optional.
$6
$11
Broaster Chicken® Chopped Salad
Fresh romaine served ice cold with our signature broasted chicken, avocado slices, thick-cut bacon, tomatoes, bleu cheese, and creamy garlic dressing.
$11
Main Plates
All main plates come with 1 side choice of homemade potato salad, homemade coleslaw, or french fries unless otherwise noted.
TWO IF BY LAND...
$10 | $13
Our Speciality: Genuine Broaster Chicken®
“Broasting®” is a unique cooking method developed in 1954 combining the principles of a pressure cooker and a traditional fryer into one process. The result is a far higher quality and much more flavorful chicken. Choose 2 or 3 pieces of our original recipe chicken, served with french fries.
$10 | $13
$10
Grilled Chicken B.L.T.
Organic, free range grilled chicken, served on a pile of thick-cut bacon, lettuce, and tomatoes. Served on white, wheat, or Texas toast.
$10
$9
Certified Angus Beef® Burger
Hand pressed Certified Angus Beef® on a toasted brioche bun with fresh lettuce, tomatoes, and onion. Add American, cheddar, bleu or provolone cheese (+1). Add bacon, sliced avocado, mushrooms or fried onions (+1).
$9
$17
Certified Angus Beef® Pot Roast
24-hour slow-cooked Certified Angus Beef® pot roast, served with homemade mashed potatoes and gravy.
$17
$12
Kathy’s Home Cooked Certified Angus Beef® Pot Roast Sandwich
Pot roast the way Kathy likes it: with thick-cut bacon, boursin cheese, and caramelized onions, all pressed between two slices of thick garlic texas toast.
$12
$11
Classic Philly Cheese Steak
Prime rib sliced fine with original recipe cheese sauce and spices, served on a classic Philly-style hero roll. Add mushrooms or peppers + onions (+1).
$11
$29
New York Strip
The NY cut comes from the short loin of the cow, a muscle that does little work and makes the meat particularly tender. Cooked any way you like it, served with mashed potatoes and veggies.
$29
One if by sea...
$12
Classic Fish and Chips
Beer battered and lightly fried fish with crispy french fries, served with homemade lime tartar sauce.
$12
Mahi Mahi or Shrimp $14 | Chicken $10
Sergio’s Scintillating Taco Platter
Named for our dear friend Sergio, enjoy 3 great Southern California-style tacos served with tortilla chips, salsa, 3-cheese blend, and sour cream. Add homemade guacamole (+3).
Mahi Mahi or Shrimp $14 | Chicken $10
Mahi Mahi $20 | Grouper $23
Ocean Fresh Catch of the Day
Grilled, blackened or fried, served with rice and veggies.
Mahi Mahi $20 | Grouper $23
$12
Cook Your Catch, Overseas-style
Bring your fish out back to our kitchen and have it prepared like our fresh catch. Grilled, blackened or fried, served with rice and veggies.
$12
$17
Key Zest-y Shrimp Pasta
Key West pink shrimp sautéed with EVOO, grape tomatoes, fresh basil, parmesan cheese, and fresh lemon zest.
$17
From the Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation: Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.
Extra Goods
$3
Homemade Potato Salad
$3
Homemade Cole Slaw
Caribbean Island Rice
Black Beans
Fresh Grilled Veggie of the Day
French Fries
Mashed Potato Wedges
Homemade Mashed Potatoes
Side Salad with Main
$5
Side Sid’s Caesar with Main
$5
Desserts
$6
Key’s Favorite Key Lime Pie
$6
$7
New York Style Cheesecake
$7
$6
Devilish Chocolate Cake
$6
$7
Hot Fudge Sundae
$7
Cocktails and Libations
Cocktails
$20
The 7 Mile Smile®
An Overseas original, we mix 51 oz. of rum and deliciousness for the perfect Keys cocktail: Kraken rum, Rum Haven Coconut, amaretto, peach schnapps, fresh homemade sour mix, orange juice, mango puree, and a splash of grenadine, all topped with a dark rum floater of Myers’s. Ideal for 2 people or 1 brave soul!
$20
$8
Storm Surge
Our spin on the dark and stormy on the high seas: we blend Papa’s Pilar dark rum, orange Curacao, a dash of orange bitters, fresh squeezed lime juice, and ginger beer.
$8
$8
McQ's Margarita
A fresh squeezed margarita that will bring you right back to the good ole days: made with Reposado Tequila, Cointreau, Agave Nectar, and fresh squeezed lime juice. Rock salt comes standard, but let us know if you’d rather yours plain.
$8
$8
O Holy Mary
Say a prayer before drinking our original recipe Bloody Mary, made with St. George Green Chile vodka and our homemade Bloody Mary mix. It’s a little spicy, but let’s face it: so are you!
$8
$8
Boulevardier
A close cousin of the Negroni, we mix Bulleit bourbon, Campari, sweet vermouth, and a dash of orange bitters for a smooth finish.
$8
$8
Blueberry Bloom
Wake up your mouth with this refreshing mix of Skyy Blueberry, freshly muddled blueberries, peach schnapps, and watermelon juice.
$8
$8
Caribbean Derby
You’re in the heart of the American Caribbean, so enjoy a refreshing mix of honey and pecan infused Bourbon, fresh squeezed lemon juice, and ginger beer to kick back and relax.
$8
24 Beers on Tap
Amstel Lite
Arcus IPA
Bell’s Two Hearted Ale
Big Storm Pilsner
Budweiser
Bud Light
Coors
Corona
Darwin Summer Day IPA
Foster’s Lager
Green Flash Jibe
Guinness Draught
Heineken
M.I.A. Miami Weiss
M.I.A. Tourist Trappe
Miami Brewing Co. Shark Blue
Michelob Ultra
Miller Lite
Monkey Fist
New Belgium Folly Citradelic
New Castle
Shipyard Export Ale
Sierra Nevada
Two Henrys 7 Mile Bridge IPA